Gaia GPS
  • Home
  • Adventures
    • User Stories
    • Activities
      • Backcountry Skiing
      • Boating
      • Emergency Response
      • Fishing
      • Offroading
  • Out and Back Podcast
    • Gaia GPS

      Earn Your Turns: Learn How to Backcountry Ski…

      January 4, 2021

      Gaia GPS

      Lessons from the Trail: Best Out and Back…

      December 28, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      Buried Alive: Bruce Tremper Shares His Avalanche Story

      December 21, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      Avalanche Safety with Snow Science Expert Bruce Tremper

      December 10, 2020

      Backcountry Skiing

      The Best Winter Backcountry Tips from Search and…

      November 23, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      Courtney Dauwalter: From Science Teacher to Endurance Superstar

      November 10, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      2020 Fastest Known Time Round-Up with Buzz Burrell

      October 26, 2020

  • News
    • New Maps
    • New Features
    • Gaia GPS News
  • Shop Swag
Gaia GPS
  • Home
  • Adventures
    • User Stories
    • Activities
      • Backcountry Skiing
      • Boating
      • Emergency Response
      • Fishing
      • Offroading
  • Out and Back Podcast
    • Gaia GPS

      Earn Your Turns: Learn How to Backcountry Ski…

      January 4, 2021

      Gaia GPS

      Lessons from the Trail: Best Out and Back…

      December 28, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      Buried Alive: Bruce Tremper Shares His Avalanche Story

      December 21, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      Avalanche Safety with Snow Science Expert Bruce Tremper

      December 10, 2020

      Backcountry Skiing

      The Best Winter Backcountry Tips from Search and…

      November 23, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      Courtney Dauwalter: From Science Teacher to Endurance Superstar

      November 10, 2020

      Gaia GPS

      2020 Fastest Known Time Round-Up with Buzz Burrell

      October 26, 2020

  • News
    • New Maps
    • New Features
    • Gaia GPS News
  • Shop Swag

Facebook – Culture of Coercion

by Andrew Johnson September 25, 2011
by Andrew Johnson September 25, 2011

I started using FourSquare recently – I’m now the Mayor of San Pablo Park, and I check in there everyday. My wife and I just moved to a new neighborhood, and it’s strangely fun to log our daily walks. It’s also been neat to run into other FourSquare users, after recognizing pictures of their dogs.

After using FourSquare for a couple weeks, I was poking around their website, and I decided to connect with all of my various social utilities and import my contacts. I did them all – GMail, Twitter, and of course Facebook. Of all the services, I felt betrayed only by Facebook – that was the only one that took the excuse of me inviting my contacts to also sign me up for Wall Posts. I will almost never connect with a Facebook app for this reason – nearly all app makers will ask you for a slew of permissions, among them making public posts on your behalf.

So after the first wall post I nipped it in the bud, using the convenient way Facebook provides to remove the permission, available from the Wall Post itself. I think the Facebook employees would tell you that the system is working, and they would point out how easy it was for me to get what I wanted in the end. Each application explicitly asks you to post stuff, and you have to explicitly say yes. And then it’s easy to fix things on the back end.

I would argue that both this system and the attitude that fosters it are broken. In almost all cases, I simply say no, and decline to trade my privacy for the small bit of utility of an app. But is everyone like me? How many of these users facing these coercive choices are unable to understand the devil’s bargain they are making? How many are drunk, sad, or lonely? Heck, how many of these people are even old enough to be entering into binding agreements like this? Children who connect with their FourSquare friends on Facebook, and then end up posting automatically to their walls are being exploited in the same way as child actors – the only difference is that child actors are protected by contracts and labor law, and they get paid.

In the end, the Facebook API is a system of coercion. It preys on our weakness for being social, for being cool, and being part of the group. It preys on laziness. And it preys on our children. It’s not exactly a gun to the head, but then again the system isn’t trying to coerce you into handing over the money in the safe, so they don’t really need a gun. This light, social coercion is enough.

Facebook holds up the straw man of simplicity of UI. They claim that the interface makes it easy for you to share and control that sharing, but the simple truth is the interface makes it simple for programmers to coerce you into doing what they want.

The main problem is that applications use the carrot of things like “connect with your friends” to get you to also allow them to post on your wall. This simply should not be allowed – if FourSquare wants to connect me with my Facebook friends, they should not be allowed to ask for other permissions, most importantly they should not be allowed to ask for the Posting Publicly Permission. I can hardly blame FourSquare for this – they basically need to do it to keep up with other apps, but I can blame Facebook for making the rules of the game. This all starts higher up, in the form of a thought in Mark Zuckerberg’s head, that privacy is dead. But it does not manifest until it becomes this API.

The solution is apparent – the API should let you ask for just one permission at a time, for the thing that your app wants to do. At the very least, it should not allow developers to use the ultimate social tool – the contacts import – to erode your privacy. Until this changes, Facebook will never be a trustworthy system, and user ire will build and foment. The end result is unclear, but I think Facebook underestimates the growing tide, and there will be some consequences in the form of lawsuits, regulation, or platform change.

UI simplicity is a straw man – Facebook simply knows that favoring viral spamminess and coercion is a sure way to grow the network, and they will continue to develop the platform that way and hide behind a veil of good intentions and engineering issues. Until there is a change of heart at the highest level, or until people and our governments take action, Facebook’s attitude will continue to define social on the web.

Facebookpersonal essay
0
FacebookTwitterRedditEmail
Andrew Johnson

Andrew founded Gaia GPS. He writes code and manages the business.

previous post
How Freelancers are Like Terrorists
next post
We Roll Like Nordstrom – Money back, No Questions Asked

You may also like

Discover New Trails and Review Trip Stats with...

January 14, 2021

Greening Youth Foundation Empowers Youth and Enriches Outdoors

January 13, 2021

Winter Fat Biking Guide

January 5, 2021

Identify Avalanche Terrain with the New High-Res, Worldwide...

January 5, 2021

Earn Your Turns: Learn How to Backcountry Ski...

January 4, 2021

Gaia GPS Year in Review: CarPlay plus New...

December 28, 2020

Lessons from the Trail: Best Out and Back...

December 28, 2020

How to Use Maps to Help Avoid Avalanches

December 22, 2020

Buried Alive: Bruce Tremper Shares His Avalanche Story

December 21, 2020

Find the Deepest, Lightest Powder with the New...

December 17, 2020

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

Popular Posts

  • 1

    How to Read Topographic Maps

    October 7, 2020
  • 2

    Forrest Fenn’s Treasure has been Found

    March 12, 2019
  • 3

    How to Save Phone Battery Life in the Backcountry

    August 24, 2020
  • 4

    Gaia GPS and Apple CarPlay Bring Outdoor Maps to Your Dashboard

    February 24, 2020
  • 5

    Easy to Read, Tiny to Download: The All New Gaia Topo

    January 28, 2020

Categories

  • Adventures
  • Android
  • App Comparisons
  • App Updates
  • Backcountry Skiing
  • Boating
  • Company News
  • Emergency Response
  • Featured
  • Fishing
  • Gaia GPS
  • GaiaCloud
  • Hikes
  • How-To
  • Hunting
  • iOS
  • New Features
  • New Maps
  • Newsletter
  • Offroading
  • Out and Back Podcast
  • User Profiles
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • RSS

@2020 - All Right Reserved. Gaia GPS


Back To Top